Comments on: Top 10 Movies as Good or Better Than Books They’re Based On https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/ Movie Reviews That Rock Fri, 09 Mar 2012 14:33:11 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.2.2 By: Trey Hock https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-21394 Fri, 09 Mar 2012 14:33:11 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-21394 In reply to Jacob Fisher.

Not here and for good reason. While a couple of the films are arguably as good or even better than their individual books, the films quality wavers throughout the series and on the whole they are less satisfying than the books.

]]>
By: Trey Hock https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-21393 Fri, 09 Mar 2012 14:30:57 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-21393 In reply to ts.

Either book or movie would be difficult to include, because of the experimental nature of both. The film was an achievement though.

]]>
By: Jacob Fisher https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-21392 Thu, 08 Mar 2012 14:32:43 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-21392 Where is Harry Potter?

]]>
By: ts https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-21383 Wed, 07 Mar 2012 12:51:08 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-21383 Naked Lunch

]]>
By: Donna https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11198 Mon, 31 Jan 2011 02:55:01 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11198 So happy to see you have The Silence of the Lambs on your list. I agree with every movie on your list but this one in particular left me cold. It’s been a long time since I’ve read the book but I remember my first reaction being, “what happened to Lecter’s anagrams?” I can’t remember if all or just some were absent from the book but Ted Tally, the screenwriter, did a great job with interpreting Lechter for the big screen. Bravo Ted Tally! Boo Thomas Harris!

]]>
By: name of the rose https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11197 Sun, 31 Oct 2010 20:18:06 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11197 It is easy to make films from lousy books, but how about making a film out of Hemingway, or Kafka, or Tolstoi? Well…

]]>
By: Megan https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11196 Thu, 31 Dec 2009 01:05:16 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11196 Rules of Attraction
Ordinary People
Revolutionary Road
About A Boy

]]>
By: Raff https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11195 Mon, 21 Sep 2009 17:45:40 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11195 Live And Let Die, Moonraker (seriously). Probably most of the other Fleming books I havn’t read. The Bond novels aren’t bad, they just aren’t particularly good, whereas the movies, if they’re your thing, are excellent. Ghost World was better than the comic, sorry, graphic novel, and made the interesting choice of taking a minor point in the comic and running in a different direction, almost a ‘left instead of right’ parallel universe scenario. Finally, whilst I’m a big fan of both, The Princess Bride movies was better than the book, mainly due to excellent casting and some of the best dialogue in the entire history of cinema.

]]>
By: Trey https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11194 Mon, 07 Sep 2009 15:09:38 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11194 Yeah Birdy is great. A really well done subversive Vietnam era story. It’s a shame that the book doesn’t measure up.

I actually mentioned 2001. Kubrick and Clarke developed the story together and the book and film were made simultaneously to one another. So it doesn’t really fit. Though I highly encourage all praise for any of Kubrick’s work.

]]>
By: Frank https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11193 Sun, 06 Sep 2009 01:32:10 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11193 Probably a lesser known movie/book: Birdy. I love the movie so much, I read the book, and was fairly underwhelmed. I might also throw in 2001: A Space Odyssey.

]]>
By: Eric Melin https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11192 Wed, 02 Sep 2009 16:13:35 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11192 Jesse- Wow, that’s lame. I haven’t read the books, but I love that first Bourne movie and for me the second two took a nosedive when they eliminated Marie and pretty much any interesting relationship in the entire film. Thanks for the comment!

]]>
By: Jesse https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11191 Wed, 02 Sep 2009 15:28:17 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11191 One that should be on this list is the Bourne Identity. After seeing the movie and being amazed, I bought the book. Yuck!

The movie takes many needed liberties from the book. For instance, in the movie, Bourne meets Marie (the love interest) just outside the American Embassy. He makes her a lucrative offer for a ride to Paris, where their relationship now has a chance to grow into the love it becomes. In the book, Bourne _kidnaps_ Marie, slaps her around quite a few times before she finally escapes. Bourne then rescues her from even worse dudes and Marie is struck with some bizarre form of Stockholm syndrome that causes her to fall madly in love with the man who mere hours ago was smacking her around.

]]>
By: Doc https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11190 Mon, 24 Aug 2009 02:36:56 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11190 The LOTR movie sucked.

]]>
By: Kari https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11189 Sun, 23 Aug 2009 19:17:45 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11189 this maybe a bit childish, but what about Holes? I mean the book was okay, but I loved the movies. As for the Wizard of Oz, the book wasnt written to be a happy sappy story, it was a commentary on the econopmic, political, and social implications ofgold vs. silver…dorthy’s slippers should have been silver not ruby!

]]>
By: Bob https://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10s/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11188 Thu, 20 Aug 2009 05:51:46 +0000 http://www.scene-stealers.com/top-10/top-10-movies-as-good-or-better-than-books-theyre-based-on/#comment-11188 FOREST GUMP!!! geez

]]>